default image for post
Is Absolute Truth Personal or Impersonal?
November 24, 2010  |  radhanath-swami

For some time, Richard (now Radhanath Swami) had been troubled by a fundamental philosophical dispute over whether God was ultimately impersonal or personal. On the one hand, he had heard some yogis and philosophers profess that ultimately God is impersonal and formless. All form and personality, according to the impersonalists, is a nonpermanent product of material illusion. In the final state of liberation, the soul sheds its temporary identity and becomes one with God, merging into the all-pervading spiritual existence. On the other hand, Richard had also heard other yogis and philosophers profess that God is the Supreme Person, that His spiritual form is eternal, full of knowledge and bliss. At the time of liberation, the soul enters into the kingdom of God where it eternally serves the all-beautiful Personality of God in pure love.

Srila Prabhupada answered his doubt “We must first understand the inconceivable nature of God. The Supreme Lord is simultaneously personal and impersonal. It is an eternal truth that He is both formless and that he has an eternal, blissful form.” Radhanath Swami heard from Srila Prabhupada that the Lord’s impersonal, all-pervading energy is called Brahman. And Bhagavan is the personal form of God, who is the energetic source and never under the influence of illusion. He gave the example of the sun. The form of the sun as a planet and the formless sunlight can never be separated, as they exist simultaneously. They are different aspects of the sun. Similarly, there are two different schools of transcendentalists who focus on different aspects of the one truth. The impersonalists strive to attain liberation in the Lord’s impersonal, formless light, while the personalists strive for eternal loving service to the Lord’s all-attractive form. There is no contradiction. Srila Prabhupada revealed to Richard (now Radhanath Swami) that the two schools, personalists and impersonalists, both approach different aspects of the One God.

Radhanath Swami felt that with these simple and intelligent words, Srila Prabhupada had harmonized two apparently opposing views and completely removed all his confusions.

Radhanath Swami also gives simple examples to explain the profound truths of spiritual sciences. He explains that when we look at a mountain from a distance, we may see a hazy cloud, and if we come nearer, we may see something green. If we actually climb the mountain, we will find many houses, trees and animals. Our vision is of the same mountain, but due to our different positions we see haze, greenery or variety. In the final stage, there are varieties—trees, animals, men, and houses. Similarly the same absolute truth is perceived differently by different seekers. Radhanath Swami once narrated a story to drive home this point:

Once a railway line was laid for the first time in a village. When a train was about to come for the first time, hundreds of villagers gathered. When the train appeared in the distance, one man saw the smoke emanating from the engine at a kilometre’s distance and ran into the village and shouted, “I have seen the train; it is simply a big smoke”. A second man waited longer and observed a bright light coming towards the platform. He ran into the village and proclaimed, “I know what a train is all about. It is just a big bright light. That’s all.” A third man waited longer for the train to arrive at the station. When the train arrived and stopped, he met the driver, who came out from the locomotive. A fourth man, who waited till the end, understood that not only was there a driver, but there were hundreds and thousands of passengers sitting in the bogies connected to the locomotive. Now the fourth man could give a complete picture of what a train was all about. Similarly, a materialist thinks that there is nothing beyond this smoke-like material world. Their philosophy of life is to eat, drink and be merry. The impersonalists know certain  truth about God; they  think God is a big bright impersonal light. The yogi thinks God is the greatest personality behind the cosmic machinery of this universe. The bhakta or devotee knows another aspect – God and His energies, the material and spiritual, and the sweet loving relationships between the Lord and His part-and-parcel living entities.

Thus the scriptures, when understood under the guidance of sincere seekers of truth do not appear confusing. I am indeed fortunate to read and hear Radhanath Swami regularly.

Related Posts:



41 Comments


  1. True personalist realization of God is the highest as described in all the scriptures. But one which is the highest may not necessarily be the easiest to understand. So one requires a self realized soul like Radhanath Swami to lead one to the correct conclusion.

    View Comment
  2. Personalism versus impersonalism – this debate is an ongoing subject for thousands of years, which can mislead a spiritual seeker. But under the guidance of true seers like Radhanath Swami and his predecessors, one is saved from going astray

    View Comment
  3. A true Guru, or a spiritual master, removes all doubts and imparts real knowledge to us. As Srila Prabhupada did with Radhanath Swami, so is the latter doing with his many dedicated followers- bringing all of the closer to GOD with his teachings.

    View Comment
  4. Srila Prabhupada charmed the heart of Radhanath Swami Maharaj by resolving the contradiction between impersonal and personal features of the Lord. It is important to understand that diffrent persons may be approaching diffrent aspects of the same God and thus there is no need of conflicts in the name of religion.

    View Comment
  5. I agree with both Rajath and Ankur, my pals.

    View Comment
  6. one requires a self realized soul like Radhanath Swami to lead one to the correct conclusion.Thank you swamiji for this wonderful teaching.

    View Comment
  7. Radhanath Swami has given very nice message here. Thank you very much Radhanath Swami.

    View Comment
  8. Nice example of train….easily understood by people like me.
    H.H.Radhanath Swami Maharaj ki jai

    View Comment
  9. I just love the analogy between the villagers outlook to a train and the different aspects of God. This example makes it so clear, in such a simple way, the personal and impersonal forms of God.

    View Comment
  10. Thank you very much for sharing.

    View Comment
  11. Even in christianity it is said that man is made in the image of god so god is definitely a person.

    View Comment
  12. Wonderfully clarified through these three nice analogies

    View Comment
  13. Wonderfully summarized with simple examples.

    View Comment
  14. Thankyou for sharing such a transparent explanation of the most profound philosophy by Radhanath Swami.

    View Comment
  15. Wonderful explanation of God’s all encompassing nature!

    View Comment
  16. The Supreme Lord is simultaneously personal and impersonal

    View Comment
  17. This is a very simple explanation by HH Radhanath Swami with lucid examples to clearly understand both impersonal and personal features of one God. The story narrated by HH Radhanath Swami of a train is very nice to read and relate to these aspects of God.

    View Comment
  18. Great blog. I come back here regularly for enlightening posts….

    View Comment
  19. Radhanath Swami Fan Club Ki JAI!!!!!

    View Comment
  20. What is God if He cannot be both personal and impersonal, as well as anything beyond our conception? He is omnipotent so He can be whatever He chooses to be!

    View Comment
  21. One can only understand God by the guidance and help of saintly people like Radhanath Swami

    View Comment
  22. thank you

    View Comment
  23. Really, when heard from saints like Radhanath Swami, scriptures dont appear confusing at all!

    View Comment
  24. As we go deeper,we realize the true meaning of all the scriptures….deep study facilitates more and faster progress…..

    View Comment
  25. Such deep knowledge explained in such a simple way by Radhanath Swami Maharaj

    View Comment
  26. Wonderful explanation by Maharaj.

    View Comment
  27. Thank you Maharajah for explaining so clearly the true nature of the Lord, Personal as well as impersonal.

    View Comment
  28. The analogies of sun, mountain & train clears all misconceptions about whether God is personal or impersonal….thanks…….

    View Comment
  29. Thank you very much for sharing the words “God and His energies, the material and spiritual, and the sweet loving relationships between the Lord and His part-and-parcel living entities”

    View Comment
  30. Very nice and simple expression of a profound confusion of many Indians. Thank you!

    View Comment
  31. Beautiful instructive article…..

    View Comment
  32. Wonderful information for all.

    View Comment
  33. Great Analogy..

    View Comment
  34. Very convincing understanding…Its makes my mind clear of all doubts and now i know that God has an impersonal feature but that is not all about Him, He has a personal form also, far more superior than ours….

    Thank you Radhanath swami.

    View Comment
  35. A self-realized soul like Srila Prabhupada can bring the most complex spiritual topics to the level of the common person, and convince him.

    View Comment
  36. How wonderfully Maharaj has expalined the difference between impersonalism and personalism.

    View Comment
  37. Deep Prakash Nishad

    Thankyou for sharing such a transparent explanation of the most profound philosophy by Radhanath Swami.

    View Comment
  38. Thank you very much for sharing. Prabhupada says once, by seeing the Krishna’s form how can one say that God is only impersonal.

    View Comment
  39. Thank you very much for sharing. It helps us for preaching.

    View Comment

Leave a Reply